The Halo Effect: How Your Brand Architecture Can Make or Break Your Product

Think about your favourite band. The lead singer has incredible charisma, so you just assume the guitarist is a genius and the drummer is a virtuoso. That spillover of positive feeling—from one known quality to other, unknown ones, is the halo effect. It’s one of the most powerful cognitive biases in the human brain. And in branding, it’s a weapon that most companies leave rusting in the shed.

They launch new products as lonely orphans, forcing each one to fight for attention from scratch. That’s not a strategy; it’s malpractice.

The brutal truth is that a single, successful “hero” product can create a powerful halo that lifts your entire portfolio, slashing customer acquisition costs and accelerating growth. At CUT THRU, we don’t just build successful brands; we architect portfolios that turn one win into many. We use the science of the halo effect to multiply brand equity, because winning once is good, but building a system that wins repeatedly is how you dominate a market.
‍

The Graveyard of Bad Brand Extensions

Most brands fail at portfolio expansion because they fundamentally misunderstand the halo effect. They think their logo is a magic wand that can be slapped onto any random product. This leads to the graveyard of infamous brand extensions—think Colgate Kitchen Entrees or Harley-Davidson Perfume. These failures weren’t just bad products; they were a catastrophic misreading of the brand’s core halo.

This isn’t just a historical problem. The 2024 Edelman Trust Barometer shows that 69% of consumers reject brands with an inconsistent or confusing portfolio. When a brand known for rugged motorcycles tries to sell you a delicate fragrance, it creates cognitive dissonance. It doesn’t just fail to sell the new product; it damages the credibility of the original. A poorly managed portfolio doesn’t just stall growth; it actively erodes the brand equity you worked so hard to build.
‍

The Halo Engine: A Framework for Portfolio Amplification

A powerful brand portfolio isn’t built by accident. It’s engineered. Our framework is a systematic process for defining, extending, and measuring your brand’s halo to ensure every new product launches with an unfair advantage.
‍

Pillar 1: Define Your Core Halo (Identify Your Superpower)

Before you can extend a halo, you must be able to articulate it in a single, powerful concept. What is the one core promise that your customers associate with your hero product? Is it simplicity? Reliability? Design excellence? This is your brand’s superpower.

In Action: PaperformFor our client Paperform, a powerful SaaS tool, we identified their core halo as “effortless power.” Their product allows users to create incredibly sophisticated forms and workflows with beautiful simplicity. This concept became our strategic filter. Every new feature, template, or integration must reinforce this core promise. A new feature that is powerful but complicated dilutes the halo. A feature that is simple but weak also fails the test. This ruthless focus ensures that every portfolio expansion strengthens their core brand identity.
‍

Pillar 2: Build Cohesive Architecture (Logical Connections)

As marketing scientists Byron Sharp and Jenni Romaniuk have proven, brands grow through building distinctive, recognisable assets. A cohesive portfolio uses these assets to create logical connections between products, making it easy for consumers to transfer their trust.

In Action: HylohFor Hyloh, a premium architectural hardware brand, their core halo is “considered design.” Their product range is a masterclass in cohesive architecture. When they expand from door handles to cabinet pulls or wall hooks, they use the exact same minimalist aesthetic, the same commitment to material honesty, and the same precision engineering. The halo of quality and design excellence transfers seamlessly because the underlying brand DNA is identical across the entire portfolio.
‍

Pillar 3: Leverage Brand Ambassadors (Transferring Trust)

The most credible messengers for a new product are the loyal customers of your existing products. Their authentic advocacy is infinitely more powerful than any ad campaign.

In Action: BlossomOur client Blossom built a powerful halo of trust by making investing feel simple and accessible. When they decided to launch a new, more advanced savings feature, their most valuable asset was their existing user base. We helped them design a beta program that gave their most loyal users early access. These “superfans” became the new feature’s primary ambassadors, sharing their positive experiences on social media and providing invaluable, trustworthy social proof that validated the new product for a broader audience.
‍

Pillar 4: Measure the Transfer (Data-Driven Optimisation)

As marketing effectiveness experts Les Binet and Peter Field have shown, you can’t just trust that your strategy is working; you must measure it. For the halo effect, this means tracking not just the performance of the new product, but its synergistic effect on the entire portfolio.

In Action: Talent RecapFor Talent Recap, a global media brand, their portfolio includes articles, videos, and podcasts. When they launch a new podcast series, we don’t just measure downloads. We use data to measure the halo transfer. We track metrics like:
‍

• Did a banner for the new podcast on a popular article increase the average time-on-site for that article?
  ‍
• Do podcast listeners visit the website more frequently than non-listeners?
  ‍
• Did social media engagement increase during the podcast’s launch week?This data-driven approach proves that the new product isn’t just performing well on its own; it’s making the entire brand ecosystem stronger.
  ‍

Implementation Guide: An Ethical Halo Strategy

1. Define Your Core Halo: What is the single most powerful promise your brand makes? Articulate it clearly, like Paperform’s “effortless power.” This is your strategic anchor.
   ‍
2. Audit Your Portfolio for Coherence: Does every product in your portfolio feel like it comes from the same brand? If not, you have a broken halo. We worked with Hyloh to ensure their design language was ruthlessly consistent.
   ‍
3. Run Split Tests on Messaging: When launching a new product, test messages that explicitly link it to your hero product’s halo against messages that don’t. The data will show you the power of the connection.
   ‍
4. Activate Your Superfans: Build a beta program or an ambassador community like we did for Blossom. Empower your most loyal customers to be the champions of your new offerings.
   ‍
5. Seek an Expert Opinion: It’s difficult to see the inconsistencies in your own portfolio. An objective audit from the best branding agency in Sydney can provide a clear-eyed analysis and a strategic roadmap for building a more cohesive and powerful brand architecture.
   ‍

Common Halo Effect Pitfalls to Avoid

• Inconsistent Branding: If your new product looks and sounds completely different from your hero product, you’re breaking the halo. Cohesion is non-negotiable.
  ‍
• Overstretched Halos: Just because you make a great investment app doesn’t mean your customers want a fashion line from you. The new product must be a logical extension of your brand’s expertise and promise.
  ‍
• Fake Expertise: Don’t claim a halo you haven’t earned. If your brand is known for simplicity, don’t suddenly launch a complex enterprise product without a clear strategy to prove your competence in that new area.
  ‍
• Ignoring Data: Don’t just assume your halo is working. Track cross-category metrics and customer behaviour to prove that your portfolio is creating synergistic value.
  ‍

The Future of Halo-Driven Branding

In an increasingly fragmented and noisy market, a strong, coherent brand halo is more valuable than ever. It’s a powerful signal of trust and quality that helps consumers navigate a sea of infinite choice. AI-driven analytics will make it even easier for brands to measure and optimise halo effects across their portfolios. But the core principle will remain the same. The brands that win will be those that build a unified, logical, and powerful brand architecture where every product makes every other product stronger.

Is your brand portfolio a team of all-stars or a collection of disconnected solo acts? Partner with CUT THRU, the leading branding agency in Sydney and New York, to build a cohesive, halo-driven brand that multiplies your success.

Click here to get a quote for elevating your brand’s growth and loyalty.

About The Author

Jonathan Sankey is founder of CUT THRU, recognised for conversion-centred design and product-market fit testing. His evidence-based approach has driven growth for global brands and unicorn startups in Australia and America. A Netty Award winner (2023, 2024), he blends data with execution.

‍Click Here to Follow Jonathan on LinkedIn for a New Brand Hack Every Week.