The Subtle Art of Framing: Shaping Consumer Perception in Brand Marketing

The world’s most successful hackers weren’t masters of code; they were masters of psychology. Legends like Kevin Mitnick could get a CEO’s password not by cracking encryption, but by “social engineering”—masterfully framing a request so that handing over the keys felt like the most natural and logical thing to do. This is the power of framing. It’s the art of shaping the context to make your desired outcome the inevitable choice.

And most brands are terrible at it.

The brutal truth is that if you don’t deliberately frame the value of your product, your customer will. And they will almost always default to the least favourable frame: a simple, brutal price comparison. At CUT THRU, we don’t just market products; we engineer perception. We use the science of framing to control the narrative, build unshakeable value, and turn consideration into conversion, all without a hint of deception.
‍

The Value Vacuum: Why Unframed Offers Fail

When a customer encounters an unframed offer, they are in a value vacuum. They lack the context needed to make a confident decision. Is this product a bargain or a rip-off? Is this tier the right one for me? This uncertainty leads to cognitive friction, which in turn leads to two disastrous outcomes: decision paralysis or a race to the bottom on price.

Worse still are brands that use deceptive framing. As the 2024 Edelman Trust Barometer shows, 72% of consumers will abandon a brand after uncovering manipulative tactics. A fake “was” price, a misleading bundle, or a false comparison doesn’t just fail to persuade; it actively destroys the trust that is the bedrock of any valuable brand. Framing isn’t a choice; it’s a necessity. The only choice is whether you do it ethically and effectively, or not at all.
‍

The Perception Blueprint: Five Frames for Shaping Value

Ethical framing isn’t about hiding the truth; it’s about illuminating the most compelling version of it. Our framework is a system for applying proven psychological frames to your brand and offers, ensuring your value is not just seen, but felt.
‍

1. The Context Frame (Setting the Stage)

The Psychology: Nothing exists in isolation. Our perception of an object is profoundly influenced by the environment in which we see it.The Dark Tactic: Placing a mediocre product next to a terrible one to make it look good by comparison, or creating a misleading bundle of low-value items to create the illusion of a great deal.The Ethical Counter: Frame your product in the context of excellence.For our client Hyloh, a premium architectural hardware brand, the product is never shown in isolation. It is framed within the context of award-winning architecture and high-end interior design. By placing their products in these aspirational settings, we are not selling a door handle; we are selling a piece of a masterpiece. The context elevates the product’s perceived value far beyond its material cost.
‍

2. The Gain/Loss Frame (The Power of Aversion)

The Psychology: As Daniel Kahneman’s work proved, humans are far more motivated to avoid a loss than to acquire an equivalent gain. How you frame an offer—as a gain or as the avoidance of a loss—has a dramatic impact on its appeal.The Dark Tactic: Using high-pressure tactics that invent a fake, imminent loss, such as a fake countdown timer on an offer that never actually expires.The Ethical Counter: Frame the choice in terms of avoiding a real, tangible loss.For Paperform, a SaaS tool, their annual plan offers a significant discount over the monthly subscription. We can frame this as “Save 20% with an annual plan” (a gain). But a more powerful frame is to show the total monthly cost crossed out, highlighting the higher amount the customer avoids losing by choosing the annual plan. This leverages loss aversion in a completely transparent and ethical way.
‍

3. The Decoy Frame (Guiding the Choice)

The Psychology: The decoy effect is a cognitive bias where people’s preference for one of two options changes when a third, asymmetrically dominated option is added.The Dark Tactic: Creating a ridiculously overpriced “decoy” option with few features, designed solely to make the mid-tier option look like an incredible bargain, even if it’s not.The Ethical Counter: Use transparent tiers to make the value clear.We worked with Paperform to structure their pricing into clear Pro, Business, and Enterprise tiers. The Business plan is strategically priced to be the most attractive option for the majority of their target customers. It’s only slightly more expensive than Pro but offers significantly more value, making it the logical choice. The Enterprise plan serves as a high-end anchor, but all three tiers offer genuine, distinct value.
‍

4. The Attribute Frame (Owning One Word)

The Psychology: People can only hold one or two key ideas about a brand in their minds. The attribute frame involves deliberately highlighting a single, powerful quality to the exclusion of all others.The Dark Tactic: Making a false or exaggerated claim about a single attribute, like “greenwashing” a product’s environmental credentials.The Ethical Counter: Identify your most powerful, authentic attribute and own it.For Blossom, an investment app, they could talk about returns, security, or fund diversity. But they choose to frame their entire brand around a single attribute: simplicity. Every piece of marketing, every UI element, and every line of copy reinforces the frame that Blossom is the easiest way to start growing your savings. This singular focus makes them incredibly memorable and appealing to their target audience.
‍

5. The Competitor Frame (Defining the Alternative)

The Psychology: How you frame your competitors can be as important as how you frame yourself.The Dark Tactic: Making false or misleading claims about your rivals, which is not only unethical but often illegal.The Ethical Counter: Reframe the entire category to your advantage.For Talent Recap, a media brand for fans of TV talent shows, they don’t attack their competitors by name. Instead, they frame the market as “superficial gossip sites vs. the home of real, passionate expert analysis.” This frame doesn’t just elevate their brand; it simultaneously reframes the entire competitive set as inferior without resorting to negative attacks.
‍

Implementation Guide: An Ethical Framing Strategy

1. Audit Your Current Frames: Review your product pages. How are you framing your value? Is it clear and compelling, or are you creating a value vacuum?
   ‍
2. Define Your Attribute Frame: What is the one word or concept you want to own, like Blossom’s “simplicity”? Ensure your entire brand reinforces this frame.
   ‍
3. Architect Your Pricing Tiers: Use the decoy effect ethically to guide users to your most popular or valuable plan, as we did with Paperform. Ensure every tier offers real value.
   ‍
4. Run Split Tests on Framing: Test a gain frame vs. a loss frame for your discounts. Test different contextual images for your products. We use double-blind split testing to find the most powerful ethical frames for our clients.
   ‍
5. Seek an Expert Opinion: Framing is a sophisticated psychological discipline. An audit from the best branding agency in Sydney can uncover powerful opportunities to reshape your brand’s perceived value.
   ‍

Common Framing Pitfalls to Avoid

• Fake Discounts: Using an arbitrarily inflated anchor price is a transparently deceptive tactic that destroys trust.
  ‍
• Unclear Bundles: If the customer can’t easily understand the value of a bundle, they will assume there is none.
  ‍
• False Urgency: A fake countdown timer is a sign of a desperate and untrustworthy brand.
  ‍
• Baseless Competitor Claims: Don’t make claims about your rivals you can’t back up. Focus on framing your own strengths.
  ‍

The Future of Ethical Framing

In the coming years, AI will enable brands to create hyper-personalized frames for every single user. The power of this technology will be immense, and so will the ethical responsibility that comes with it. The brands that win the future will be those that use this power to deliver greater clarity, more relevant context, and more transparent value. The fundamentals of human psychology won’t change, but the tools we use to apply them will become exponentially more powerful.

Is your brand’s value getting lost in a bad frame? Partner with CUT THRU, the leading branding agency in Sydney and New York, to build an ethical, perception-shaping strategy that drives growth.
‍
Click here to get a quote for elevating your brand’s value and growth.

About The Author

Jonathan Sankey is founder of CUT THRU, recognised for conversion-centred design and product-market fit testing. His evidence-based approach has driven growth for global brands and unicorn startups in Australia and America. A Netty Award winner (2023, 2024), he blends data with execution.

‍Click Here to Follow Jonathan on LinkedIn for a New Brand Hack Every Week.